Same trucks, more crossingsÂ
It would be easy to assume that the traffic shift means more fleets switched bridges, but that turns out to be wrong. The BWB didn’t get a wave of new users, it just got more trips from the ones it already had.Â
What the data shows is that the number of unique trucks on the BWB stayed nearly flat, while the average number of trips per vehicle rose by a remarkable 28%. Trucks are essentially making one extra crossing – from 4.4 to 5.6 per month.Â
Meanwhile, on the Ambassador Bridge, the number of unique vehicles and trips per vehicle both dropped by about 10%.
Our interpretation: Fleets that were already using the BWB started running it harder. Our hypothesis is that the toll savings per trip are making more frequent crossings economical for existing BWB users, not pulling entirely new operators away from Ambassador.
Operationally, this is a routing-frequency shift, not a full corridor realignment. Many fleets appear to be using BWB for high-frequency runs and potentially still using Ambassador for others.
As congestion rises, speed fallsÂ
With the BWB volume increase, it is now absorbing increased crossing demand. This creates a resulting decrease in travel speeds which can lead to bottlenecks.
We looked at approach roads in zones with a radius of one mile, three miles, and five miles, finding that morning approach speeds to the BWB fell by 10–14%. Motorway speeds within one mile of the bridge are down by 10% in the morning hours.Â
What this means is that although the toll savings are real, so is the time cost. The cost-benefit calculation at BWB is shifting. What looks like a clear cost savings is becoming a more nuanced calculation as congestion builds. Operators with time-sensitive loads should measure toll savings against the risk of morning delays.
The Gordie Howe Bridge wildcardÂ
When the Gordie Howe International Bridge opens, that will create a new three-bridge dynamic for the Ontario-Michigan crossing. With planned commercial tolls of about $8.75 USD per axle, Gordie Howe pricing is positioned in between the BWB and Ambassador Bridge.Â
We plan to track toll changes in real time as this dynamic unfolds. Our data will help gauge the potential redistribution of commercial vehicle travel, behavior, speed impacts and crossing frequency.Â
Ongoing data offers deeper insights
When measuring toll impacts, in-depth commercial vehicle data offers deeper insights than public datasets, revealing the “why it matters” behind freight behavior. Whether you’re a planner modeling corridor performance, or a fleet manager benchmarking crossing strategy, these data details expand the scale of what questions you can explore.Â